My Thoughts on Five Star Final
By: Bria Henry
After watching Five Star Final, I noticed how the film reflects many of the concepts we have been learning about in journalism history. One of the biggest ideas shown in the movie is yellow journalism, which focuses on sensational and emotional stories in order to attract readers and increase newspaper sales. In the film, editor Joseph Randall works for the newspaper The New York Evening Graphic and is pressured by the publisher to boost circulation. Because of this pressure, Randall agrees to reopen an old scandal about Nancy Voorhees, a woman who had been involved in a murder case years earlier. Even though Nancy has rebuilt her life and is now married to Michael Townsend, the newspaper decides to publish her past again in order to create a shocking headline that will sell more papers. This reflects how newspapers during that time often prioritized dramatic stories over the well-being of the people involved.
 |
Photo By: imdb
Five Star Final Movie Poster |
Another character who represents unethical journalism is reporter T. Vernon Isopod. While watching the movie, it became clear that Isopod is willing to do almost anything to get information for a story. He follows Nancy, pressures people connected to her, and even brings in Jenny Townsend, Nancy’s daughter from her earlier life, to expose the truth publicly. His actions show very little concern for how the story might affect Nancy and her family. Instead, his main focus is getting the story published and creating a headline that will attract readers. This behavior reflects the competitive nature of newspapers at the time and how some reporters ignored ethical responsibilities in order to succeed.
The film also made me think about the ethical obligations journalists have toward both the people they write about and the people who read their work. Journalists have a responsibility to report the truth, but they also need to consider the impact their stories may have on individuals’ lives. In Five Star Final, the newspaper staff initially seems more focused on profits and circulation than on ethics. However, as the consequences of the story unfold, Joseph Randall begins to realize that publishing Nancy’s past has caused serious harm.
Overall, watching Five Star Final showed me how powerful journalism can be and how dangerous it can become when profit and sensationalism are prioritized over ethics. The movie highlights the importance of responsible reporting and reminds viewers that journalists must balance informing the public with protecting people from unnecessary harm.